Toronto - 45 Sheppard Ave East Suite 500C - Call (416) 519-0699 | Mississauga - 2 Robert Speck Pkwy Suite 750C - Call (905) 949-1717

Navigating Child Custody and Support in Ontario Divorces

Legal Process for Determining Custody in Ontario

1. Filing for Custody

The process begins when one or both parents file a custody application, which can be done as part of filing for divorce or as a separate application if the parents are not married. The application must be filed in the Family Court branch of the Superior Court of Justice, or in a Unified Family Court, if available in the region.

2. Mediation and Dispute Resolution

Before proceeding to court, parents are often encouraged or required to seek mediation or other forms of alternative dispute resolution. This allows both parties to attempt to reach an agreement with the help of a neutral third party. Ontario offers mediation services, which can be a quicker and less confrontational route than traditional court proceedings.

3. Motion for Temporary Custody

If immediate decisions about custody need to be made before the final determination, either parent can file a motion for temporary custody. This ensures that the child’s needs are met while the court proceedings are ongoing.

4. Custody Assessment

In cases where parents cannot agree, the court may order a custody evaluation, which involves a social worker, psychologist, or other professional assessing the family situation and recommending a custody arrangement based on the best interests of the child.

5. Trial and Final Order

If custody cannot be resolved through mediation or assessments, the matter will proceed to trial. Here, evidence is presented, including the custody assessment report, and each parent can make their case for their preferred custody arrangement. The judge will then make a final decision, issuing a custody order based on the child’s best interests.

Factors Considered by Courts in Ontario When Deciding Custody Arrangements

The overriding principle in Ontario child custody cases is the best interest of the child. Several specific factors are considered by the court when determining what serves the best interest of the child:

  • Parent-Child Relationship: The emotional bonds between the child and each parent, including which parent has been the primary caregiver.
  • Parental Stability: The ability of each parent to provide a stable, secure, and nurturing environment. This includes considerations of the parent’s mental and emotional health, as well as their ability to care for the child.
  • Child’s Wishes: Depending on the age and maturity of the child, their preferences may be considered, especially if they have a strong preference for living with one parent.
  • Sibling and Family Bonds: The importance of maintaining relationships with siblings and other significant family members.
  • Parental Cooperation and Support: The ability and willingness of each parent to facilitate and encourage a close and continuing relationship between the child and the other parent, including whether a parent is likely to influence the child against the other parent.
  • Parental Conduct: Any history of violence, abuse, neglect, or substance abuse can heavily influence custody decisions.

Circumstances under Which Custody and Support Orders Can Be Modified

1. Significant Change in Circumstances: The most common basis for modifying child custody and support is a significant change in the circumstances of the child or the parents. This could include:

  • Changes in Employment: A significant increase or decrease in a parent’s income, loss of job, or a new job with different hours that affect caregiving abilities.
  • Relocation: One parent moving a considerable distance away, making the original custody and support arrangements impractical or impossible.
  • Changes in the Child’s Needs: As children grow, their needs change, which may require adjustments in both the custody arrangement and the amount of support.
  • Health of Parents or Child: Significant changes in health that affect a parent’s ability to care for the child or that change the care needs of the child.
  • Alterations in Living Conditions: Any changes that significantly affect the suitability of the living environment, such as a parent’s new partner or overcrowded living conditions.

2. Child’s Preference: Depending on the age and maturity of the child, their preference might be considered if they express a strong desire for a change in living arrangements.

3. Failure to Comply with Current Orders: If one parent consistently fails to adhere to the terms of the custody or support order, the other parent might seek a modification.

The Process for Seeking Modifications

1. Assessment of Changes: Before applying for a modification, it is important to assess whether the changes in circumstances are substantial and permanent rather than temporary.

2. Attempt to Negotiate: Parents are encouraged to try to reach a new agreement mutually before heading to court. Mediation services can also be utilized to help reach an agreement.

3. Filing a Motion: If parents cannot agree on modifications, the parent seeking change must file a motion to change with the court that issued the original order. This involves preparing and submitting the appropriate legal forms, which can be obtained from the Ontario court’s website or a legal services office.

4. Documentation: The parent must provide substantial evidence of the change in circumstances. This includes financial statements, medical reports, or other relevant documents that support the claim for modification.

5. Serving the Motion: The motion and supporting documents must be legally served to the other parent, giving them an opportunity to respond.

6. Court Hearing: Both parents will have the opportunity to present their case in a court hearing. They may bring forward witnesses and evidence to support their positions.

7. Court Decision: The judge will make a decision based on the best interests of the child, considering the new evidence and circumstances. The judge may modify the custody arrangement, the amount of support, or both.

Impact of Parental Relocation on Custody and Support Arrangements

1. Changes to Custody and Visitation: Relocation can necessitate changes to the existing custody and visitation schedules. If one parent moves away, it may become logistically challenging or impossible to maintain the same schedule, leading to less frequent but longer visits, or a shift in primary custody.

2. Alteration in Support Payments: Changes in the costs of traveling to maintain contact with the child can affect child support payments. The parent who moves might face additional expenses to facilitate visitation, which could be factored into support calculations.

3. Emotional and Social Impact on the Child: Beyond logistics, moving can affect the child’s emotional and social development. This includes potential disruptions to their education, loss of close contact with the non-relocating parent, and separation from their community and friends.

Legal Considerations and Required Procedures for Parental Relocation

The legal framework governing parental relocation in Ontario is primarily focused on the best interests of the child, guided by the principles outlined in the Children’s Law Reform Act and relevant case law.

1. Legal Threshold for Relocation: A parent wishing to relocate with a child must first consider whether the move constitutes a material change in circumstances as defined under family law. The change must be substantial enough to potentially alter the child’s well-being.

2. Mandatory Notification: The parent planning to move must provide written notice to the other parent, outlining the proposed relocation details, including the new address, the date of relocation, and the reasons for the move.

3. Objection by the Non-Relocating Parent: The non-relocating parent has the right to object to the move. This objection must be formally filed, typically triggering a legal process where the relocating parent must justify the relocation.

4. Legal Criteria for Approval: When deciding whether to allow a parent to relocate with a child, Ontario courts will consider:

  • The existing custody arrangement and relationship between the child and both parents.
  • The impact of the move on the child’s physical, emotional, and educational needs.
  • The feasibility of maintaining the child’s relationship with the non-relocating parent.
  • The child’s views and preferences, depending on their age and maturity.
  • The reasons for the move – whether it is made in good faith and not intended to impair the relationship between the child and the other parent.
  • Any legal restrictions or orders pertaining to mobility rights and obligations.

5. Court Proceedings: If parents cannot agree on the relocation, the matter will likely proceed to court. The relocating parent must file a motion to change the existing custody order. The court will then review the proposal, considering evidence from both sides, before making a decision based on what it deems to be in the best interests of the child.

Mechanisms for Enforcing Custody and Support Orders in Ontario

1. Family Responsibility Office (FRO): The FRO is a key agency in Ontario responsible for collecting, distributing, and enforcing child support payments. When a support order is issued, it is automatically filed with the FRO, unless both parties agree to opt out. The FRO uses various tools to ensure payments are made:

  • Garnishing Wages: The FRO can direct employers to deduct support payments directly from the paying parent’s wages.
  • Intercepting Federal Payments: Tax refunds and other federal payments can be intercepted to cover overdue child support.
  • Suspending Driver’s Licenses: For parents who fail to pay child support, the FRO can suspend their driver’s license.
  • Reporting to Credit Bureaus: Non-payment can be reported to credit bureaus, affecting the defaulting parent’s credit rating.

2. Enforcement of Custody Orders: While the FRO enforces support orders, custody orders are generally enforced through court actions. If a parent fails to comply with a custody order, the other parent can file a motion with the court requesting enforcement. The court has several options to enforce its orders:

  • Police Assistance: The court can issue a police enforcement clause, which authorizes the police to assist in retrieving the child.
  • Contempt of Court: If a parent willfully disobeys a custody order, they can be found in contempt of court, leading to fines or imprisonment.

Leave a comment